The Chrysler Minivan Fan Club Forums banner

Tow package or roof rack??

228 Views 13 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  2014 White Lightning
No roof rack on my S model.
$80 at pullnpay.
Install brackets available no doubt.

-or-

Tow package installation and use a quality trailer.

Any experience on one advantage over the other??
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
You can carry a considerable amount more in a small trailer than you should carry with a roof rack. I would say for a smaller utility trailer and under 1000lbs you don’t need the tow package, just the hitch and wiring for lights.
Just the hitch etc... Goin down to take a look. Roof requires awkward strapping, I'd just seen a netted teardrop rack system. Forget where I saw the aftermarket setup.
I can borrow a trailer easy
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Both here. Mine came with the roof rack...I added the trailer-towing package.

When I get to Boise, I think I'll scan the Jalopy Jungles there for helper springs... :unsure:
roof racks are painful on the back / shoulders. My van and body loves towing trailers...
  • Like
Reactions: 3
Simple trailer does seem far preferable after some thought.
Not sure how to mount the turret now, if I'm not doing roof racks 🤔😁
Well, an M61 Vulcan, naturally 😁 Long as I have CAS for any uparmored tanks.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
4
Depends how well you can back up a trailer, or if you encounter tight parking spaces (no room for a trailer). We use our 2011 Toyota Sienna for family vacation road trips, and have done both the roof bag, then the small trailer. The trailer IS easier to load/unload, less hassle with tying stuff down (just stuffed it full), and more aero dynamic because it sits level with the roofline of the van. Only problems were backing up in crowded spaces, parking (had to unhook and move it by hand at a motel one night), and places where it's not allowed (Hoover Dam; had to unhook and leave it somewhere for a while). The roof bag couldn't hold as much, and still had everything in the van so the rear sagged BAD, water eventually got inside, the straps were loose once and forgotten to attach once so it moved and got ripped, and it hit the wind. Eventually threw the roof bag away after two uses.

Our Sienna is a good match/comparison to the 5th gen Chrysler vans as far as power, suspension, and brakes. We do have twin piston front calipers, like the heavy duty brakes of the 5th gens. I really couldn't feel the trailer behind us on the highway, and braking wasn't too bad either. Being able to carry tools, a floor jack and a full size spare tire came in very handy.

This was at White Sands National Monument in New Mexico.

Wheel Tire Car Sky Cloud


Trailer IS hooked up behind us here, but it's narrow enough that you don't see it (nor does the wind).
This is just above Hoover Dam.

Sky Car Wheel Vehicle Land vehicle


At Needles National Park in South Dakota, where we had to find an out of the way place to park for a while to explore. Then we had to go through the tunnel on the right, so had to make a turn there and hope no one was coming. Can't see the trailer behind us unless people are looking for it.

Sky Cloud Wheel Tire Car


And one more pic I took at Needles because I'm proud of it. Perfect subject, perfect lighting and time of day - - the eye of the needle (where the park got it's name)... That blue spot must be a reflection from something nearby, as there is no hole there.

Cloud Sky Atmosphere World Light
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 3
Those pics are wild. Good times for sure. That smaller box trailer seems a right bet.
Experience w bag)roof rack- lessons for me. For sure
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Depends how well you can back up a trailer, or if you encounter tight parking spaces (no room for a trailer). We use our 2011 Toyota Sienna for family vacation road trips, and have done both the roof bag, then the small trailer. The trailer IS easier to load/unload, less hassle with tying stuff down (just stuffed it full), and more aero dynamic because it sits level with the roofline of the van. Only problems were backing up in crowded spaces, parking (had to unhook and move it by hand at a motel one night), and places where it's not allowed (Hoover Dam; had to unhook and leave it somewhere for a while). The roof bag couldn't hold as much, and still had everything in the van so the rear sagged BAD, water eventually got inside, the straps were loose once and forgotten to attach once so it moved and got ripped, and it hit the wind. Eventually threw the roof bag away after two uses.

Our Sienna is a good match/comparison to the 5th gen Chrysler vans as far as power, suspension, and brakes. We do have twin piston front calipers, like the heavy duty brakes of the 5th gens. I really couldn't feel the trailer behind us on the highway, and braking wasn't too bad either. Being able to carry tools, a floor jack and a full size spare tire came in very handy.

This was at White Sands National Monument in New Mexico.

View attachment 72428

Trailer IS hooked up behind us here, but it's narrow enough that you don't see it (nor does the wind).
This is just above Hoover Dam.

View attachment 72429

At Needles National Park in South Dakota, where we had to find an out of the way place to park for a while to explore. Then we had to go through the tunnel on the right, so had to make a turn there and hope no one was coming. Can't see the trailer behind us unless people are looking for it.

View attachment 72430

And one more pic I took at Needles because I'm proud of it. Perfect subject, perfect lighting and time of day - - the eye of the needle (where the park got it's name)... That blue spot must be a reflection from something nearby, as there is no hole there.

View attachment 72431
Very nice pics.
That trailer is about as ideal of an option for travel as I can think of. What are the dimensions of the trailer and do you know what the empty weight is? The only downside is that it is so short, that makes it harder to back up. But a longer tongue would increase buffeting between the vehicles.

For me the wheels would need to be as wide as my van because it drives me nuts if the trailer is invisible.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I feel like if you can't back up a trailer you shouldn't pass your initial driving test, but I Used to park jetliners like a puzzle with my tug.
Now that I said that, you know I'll scrape my next trailer 1st time out ,🤣🤣
  • Haha
Reactions: 2
I feel like if you can't back up a trailer you shouldn't pass your initial driving test, but I Used to park jetliners like a puzzle with my tug.
Now that I said that, you know I'll scrape my next trailer 1st time out ,🤣🤣
I know that it is much easier to back up a 45’ trailer than it is my 10’ trailer. I’m talking about driving backwards not trying to put the 45’ trailer in a 15’ spot.
Got me wanting to do some parking Olympics with some crazy trailer challenge 🤣🤣
  • Like
Reactions: 2
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
Top