The Chrysler Minivan Fan Club Forums banner

Just received MotoRad High Flow Thermostat - My Review

1K views 17 replies 8 participants last post by  LPete  
#1 ·
Today I received (and installed) MotorRad Thermostat Part No. 2340-195 (High Flow, 195F thermostat)
This is the "High Flow" version with larger opening for water to flow.

Standard Thermostats have a 30mm opening. These High flow thermostats have a 34mm opening.

Image


After installing the new thermostat, I re-added the exact same coolant that was drained from the system.
Here are my results.

The High Flow thermostat opens later than the one I removed. Both are 195F thermostats but the high flow thermostat seems to open later, at 200F. During a 60mph run, the high flow thermostat never allowed the coolant temp to drop below 199F. With the normal thermostat I removed, the coolant temp would usually fall to 192F during a 60mph cruise with temps slightly warmer than they were today. That does not bode well for the high flow thermostat as there seems to be a significant deviation in the advertised open set point and the actual open set point of at least 5F.

While sitting with the AC on full blast, it did "seem" to take longer for the engine to heat up than on other days, but today was about 5F cooler than the last few times I observed the temps while sitting so I cannot attribute this to the new thermostat.

Overall I am disappointed with the MotorRad 2340-195 'High Flow" thermostat. it did not deliver a noticeable change in coolant temps and actually may have raised them slightly due to a defective higher than advertised low temperature set point. Perhaps I got a bad one. I have read that Motorad thermostats are very hit or miss and that you get a bad one about as often as you get a good one.

The only possible circumstance that might change my review is if for any reason the cooling system hasn't "burped" all the air out yet. For that reason I'm going to leave the thermostat in for now and try removing any possible air in the system and try again in a few days. If the situation changes I'll let you know.

If you decide to try one and get different (hopefully better) results, please post it. Thanks
 
Discussion starter · #6 ·
I still wonder about the Motorad Superstats. The 192F has my interest. Both available on Rockauto.

View attachment 87403
The thermostat I removed was a MotorRad UltraStat 195F. I figured "Ultra" had to be better than just "Super" :ROFLMAO:

Here's their Marketing jargon for the Ultrastat.....
The Motorad Ultastat Automotive Thermostat – a pinnacle of precision engineering for your vehicle’s optimal performance. Designed with cutting-edge technology and unwavering reliability, the Ultastat thermostat ensures precise temperature regulation, enhancing engine efficiency and longevity. Its advanced control mechanism swiftly adapts to changing conditions, promoting faster warm-ups and maintaining consistent operating temperatures.

Crafted to the highest industry standards, the Motorad Ultastat guarantees seamless integration into your vehicle, empowering you with the confidence to conquer the road ahead. Elevate your driving experience with the Motorad Ultastat – where innovation meets automotive excellence.
All I heard was "yada yada yada blah blah blah"
 
Discussion starter · #7 ·
Everything is made a cheaply as possible. There is always a variance in accuracy of opening/closing temps. The thermostat is only a very small part of the restriction of the entire flow circuit of the cooling system. A larger thermostat opening is unlikely to make a difference in cooling capacity with a stock cooling system. A bigger/better rad is another story.
Ok......NOW you tell me!! Where were you BEFORE I placed the order and did all that work, superhero ??? (poking fun only)
 
Discussion starter · #8 · (Edited)
Everything is made a cheaply as possible. There is always a variance in accuracy of opening/closing temps. The thermostat is only a very small part of the restriction of the entire flow circuit of the cooling system. A larger thermostat opening is unlikely to make a difference in cooling capacity with a stock cooling system. A bigger/better rad is another story.
I'm thinking about trying that Swansong (or whatever it's called) All Aluminum radiator.
But....as you say "everything is made as cheaply as possible". So who's to say it won't run hotter than a standard SpectraPremium radiator?
And will it last a year?
It claims to be 3 row and the only indications that could be true is that it is 1.6 inches thick (supposedly) and the inlet and outlet are on the same side, indicating triple pass?.

It might take $600 - $700 to get a really good quality all aluminum radiator?
 
Discussion starter · #9 ·
If this "high flow" thermostat doesn't do any better after the system has been run a couple hundid miles, I'm putting the previous (MotoRad Ultrastat 195F) back in.
I did like the fact that that one let the engine reach 192F once on the freeway or cruising along at 60+ on 105F days.

I guess I could roll the dice and try a 180F UltraStat? (Yes, I realize it ain't gonna make much difference with the stock radiator)

I had ordered a Nissens 2 row radiator...but they sent me a 1 row, standard core radiator instead (grrrrr)...so I sent it back.
 
Discussion starter · #11 ·
So after filling the radiator again (didn't take much) and another test drive, it does seem as if it's taking longer for the engine to heat up once stopped. which is a good thing.
I would actually be happy with this thermostat IF it didn't open apparently at 200F instead of 195F
 
Discussion starter · #12 ·
Just for testing, I took another Motorad 2340-195 and pre tested it in a boiling pot of waterr.

It began to first open at 196F and was fully open by 205F
I'm thinking a 192F High Flow thermostat (Motorad 2040-192) might be ideal for those of us in hotter climates.
I just ordered a handful of them and will post the results soon.
 
Discussion starter · #14 ·
Me personally, I would prefer the running at 200 over 192. It would be interesting if you saw any difference in fuel economy between the 2. In theory the higher the coolant temp the more the computer leans the mixture. I don’t know if 8 degrees makes a difference though.
Good question.
I wonder if there a table in the ECU that adjusts according to presets or if it just defaults to leaner at a set temp etc.
Seems like there would be quite a few variables that the ECU would use to adjust the mixture...altitude, coolant temp, ambient temp, load etc etc